The Las Vegas Raiders face a pivotal call on Isaiah Pola-Mao—with his role, contract future, and the defense’s direction all hanging in the balance.
The Raiders selecting Treydan Stukes in the second round of the 2026 NFL draft is a reasonable football decision. Calling it a coronation that immediately renders Pola-Mao a backup is something else entirely, and that conclusion moves faster than the evidence warrants.
Pola-Mao had a difficult 2025 season. That’s fair to say. But the Raiders surrendered the third-most points in the NFL last year under Pete Carroll’s scheme, a system that asked its safeties to carry weight that the front seven and cornerback room couldn’t support. Singling out Pola-Mao as the weakest link on that defense requires selectively ignoring how badly the entire unit underperformed around him. Defensive failures are systemic before they are individual.
The Raiders made the right call…
The extension Pola-Mao signed, two years and $7.45 million, was handed out by the same front office now drafting his presumed replacement. John Spytek doesn’t strike deals carelessly. If Pola-Mao were truly a liability beyond salvaging, the more financially disciplined move would have been to let him play out his deal or find a cheaper bridge option.
Instead, the Raiders committed real money to him months before spending a second-round pick on Stukes. That’s a depth chart with competition built in, not one that’s already been decided.
Stukes is an intriguing prospect, but let’s be honest about what he is right now. He spent most of his college career as a slot cornerback and box safety at Arizona. The “consensus among NFL personnel” that he can translate to free safety at the professional level is projection, not a résumé.
The NFL has seen plenty of versatile college defensive backs who looked the part on paper and then spent two or three years just trying to figure out where to line up. Stukes may be the exception. He may not be.
Related: Mark Davis receives another honor out in Las Vegas
There’s also a real possibility the argument here actually helps Pola-Mao. If Rob Leonard runs three-safety sets influenced by Mike Macdonald’s system, Pola-Mao operating closer to the line of scrimmage in a role that matches his strengths is a better version of him than last year’s model. That’s not consolation. That’s good roster construction.
Stukes deserves a legitimate shot to earn a starting role. But declaring him a Day 1 starter before he’s taken a professional snap, while writing off a player the front office just paid, is a conclusion in search of a process.
Let training camp sort it out.
*Top Photo: Heidi Fang/Las Vegas Review-Journal