Klint Kubiak’s original quarterback plan for the Las Vegas Raiders looked logical on paper, but early signs suggest it was flawed from the start.
The Raiders have built their season on a fiction. Kirk Cousins would hold down the job while Fernando Mendoza eased into the league on his own timeline. That fiction is already falling apart, and honestly, it never had much chance of surviving real practice reps.
Kubiak made his preference clear: He wanted a rookie quarterback to learn behind a veteran instead of being thrown into the lineup. It’s a sensible philosophy. Most coaches would agree. But sensible philosophies don’t survive what’s reportedly happening on the practice field, where Mendoza is already outplaying the 37-year-old Cousins. Once that becomes obvious to the other 52 players in the locker room, it stops being a coaching decision. It becomes a test of credibility.
The Raiders are already backing themselves into a corner…
And that’s really the problem the Raiders created for themselves. Signing an aging veteran quarterback while also drafting one first overall isn’t a neutral roster move. It’s a bet, really two bets stacked on top of each other: that Cousins holds the job long enough to justify his contract and that Mendoza actually needs the time to sit. Right now, both bets look shaky.
Mike Florio’s take on this cuts right to it. If Mendoza is clearly the better player in practice, what happens when Maxx Crosby notices? Or Brock Bowers? These players are not merely role players observing from the sidelines. They’re the best players on the roster, and they’re not exactly hiding their playoff ambitions. Watching a coaching staff bench the better quarterback because it fits some plan drawn up in April is the kind of thing that erodes trust fast.
Related: Maxx Crosby silences trade talk with a song but not a signature
That’s the real cost here, and it’s bigger than a quarterback controversy. It’s a locker room starting to wonder whether the people in charge are more committed to a script than to winning. Crosby has already been candid about where he thinks this franchise is headed, and his silence on this particular issue probably won’t last much longer.
Will there be pressure to start the No. 1 pick?
To be fair, none of this proves Mendoza is ready for Week 1. Beating up on a defense that’s still installing its scheme in July is nothing like reading disguised coverages with a real pass rush bearing down on Sundays. The gap between him and Cousins could easily close, or reverse, once games start counting. But that caveat doesn’t get the Raiders off the hook. The plan assumed there’d be time to figure this out later, quietly, on the organization’s own terms. Instead, the questions are showing up now, before a single preseason snap, and there’s no clean way to answer them.
Bench Mendoza, and it looks like the front office cares more about protecting a $180 million contract than fielding its best team. Play him, and it exposes the developmental plan as something that was never realistic to begin with.
If the Raiders are already facing this dilemma before training camp, it says less about their quarterback room than it does about a plan that was flawed from the start.
*Top Photo: Associated Press/Candice Ward
Sounds very straightforward to me. Let the veteran start and play a few drives. Bring the rookie in to play a couple of drives to see where he’s at. If the kid has it, he has it. Then, the rook starts. If he needs a bit more time, it will show in his play. Let’s not make this more complicated than it needs to be.