Las Vegas Raiders fans know this movie: an aging veteran arrives to steady the ship, then a rookie steals the wheel.
The Silver and Black have been here before.
In 2014, the Raiders opened their wallets for veteran Matt Schaub, installing him as the presumptive starter while second-round pick Derek Carr sat and learned. It didn’t last.
A blowout preseason performance against Seattle, paired with an elbow injury that sapped Schaub’s arm strength, pushed coach Dennis Allen to hand Carr the job before Week 1. A decision, mind you, Allen had insisted just days earlier he had no intention of making.
Twelve years later, the setup looks familiar.
The Raiders signed 37-year-old Kirk Cousins in free agency this offseason, then used the No. 1 overall pick on Fernando Mendoza, the reigning Heisman Trophy winner who led Indiana to a national title. First-year head coach Klint Kubiak has been clear that Cousins will open the season under center, calling it the obvious outcome of an offseason program in which Cousins ran with the first team from OTAs through minicamp.
Cousins isn’t approaching the job as a formality. He’s framed his mindset as staying sharp on a day-to-day basis, saying he tries not to take anything for granted and treats each practice as something to be earned. Kubiak, for his part, has said he wants Mendoza and fan-favorite backup Aidan O’Connell pushing Cousins in every rep, adding that any clean completion or quick release from the rookies should needle the veteran into raising his own level.
Right, right.
Mendoza, unlike Carr in 2014, has been careful not to frame the quarterback room as a rivalry. He’s described the competition as one built to make every quarterback on the roster better rather than to beat out any one individual. That patience has extended to his own expectations: Mendoza has said he’s comfortable waiting, focused on daily improvement and learning from the veterans around him, rather than pushing for an immediate opportunity.
Still, the on-field snapshots suggest a player closing the gap quickly. After a rocky spring in which his mechanics under center were inconsistent, Mendoza has looked sharper in training camp, including a seven-on-seven rep in which he pre-snap motioned receiver Phillip Dorsett II and delivered a tight-window strike in stride.
Related: Rob Leonard has the defense buying in but questions remain
It’s only a matter of time, right?
The real question hanging over the Raiders’ quarterback room isn’t if the handoff happens. It’s when. Cousins has held up well for most of his career, minus the Achilles tear that wrecked his 2023 season in Minnesota, but let’s be honest about what the Raiders signed him for: a bridge, not a foundation. If Las Vegas comes out flat, or if this season starts rhyming with 2014 the way it already looks like it might, the calls to bench the 37-year-old and hand it to the No. 1 pick won’t stay quiet for long.
For now, Cousins has the keys, and Mendoza is doing something Carr never really had to: sitting, smiling, and saying all the right things in front of the cameras. But patience has a shelf life in the NFL, and rookies with Heisman pedigrees don’t stay patient forever.
The moment Cousins throws his second bad interception in a loss, don’t be surprised if the “when” turns into “why not now,” and Raiders fans start counting down to the day Kirk Cousins becomes this era’s Matt Schaub.
FB: @TheRaiderRamble
*Top Photo: Ramble Illustration/Getty