The Las Vegas Raiders have a glaring offensive line problem, and one of the NFL’s best guards could be the answer. Indianapolis Colts star Quenton Nelson would be a game-changing addition, but landing him could come at a steep price.
Nelson is on pace to be one of the best interior offensive linemen of his generation. He has earned a Pro Bowl selection in each of his eight seasons and has been a first-team All-Pro three times. With contract negotiations stalled, the veteran is set to become a free agent this offseason.
That timing could be a lucky break for Las Vegas, which has to face the truth about its offensive line: it has not lived up to expectations. The running game is not a strength for this team right now.
The Raiders do have some stability up front. Kolton Miller, Tyler Linderbaum and DJ Glaze have their spots locked down for now. Left guard, however, has been a real struggle, and Nelson would fill that hole immediately. His arrival could give Las Vegas one of the best offensive lines in the NFL.
What’s the price for a Quenton Nelson trade?
The asking price for Nelson will not be small. Trades involving elite pass blockers are rare because demand is high and supply is low. When the Baltimore Ravens dealt Orlando Brown Jr. to the Kansas City Chiefs in 2021, for example, they received a first-round pick, a third-round pick, a fourth-round pick and a fifth-round pick. Brown went on to win a Super Bowl with Kansas City.
Brown plays tackle, a premium position, but Nelson is the more talented player. That means Las Vegas would likely have to offer an even larger package to complete a deal. On top of that, Nelson will want a new contract, and he will likely seek more money than Linderbaum’s $81 million deal.
Related: Did the Raiders learn from their past mistakes versus the Bills?
Should the Raiders make this trade?
A Nelson trade would delight Ashton Jeanty and Fernando Mendoza, who would benefit most from a stronger front. Still, one guard cannot fix everything. The Raiders need to add much more through the draft to build a successful future, and they are not in win-now mode after losing two games in a row.
That reality makes the price hard to justify. Indianapolis would likely demand more than the haul Baltimore received for Orlando Brown Jr., and Las Vegas would then have to pay Nelson more than Linderbaum’s $81 million. Spending that much draft capital and cap space on one player would leave less flexibility to build around Jeanty and Mendoza.
The better path is patience. Caleb Rogers and Trey Zuhn need to step up and show they can be part of the long-term solution up front. Their development matters more to this team’s future than a one-year fix at left guard.
The 2027 draft class could also change this roster dramatically. Keeping those picks gives the Raiders a chance to add young, affordable talent on both lines. An offensive line featuring Nelson would be exciting to see, but for a team still trying to find its footing, it is not a smart decision for this front office.
*Top Photo: Ramble Illustration/Getty Images